Manassas

‘It’s a LIE’: Manassas board member rips myth blaming kids’ backgrounds for poor scores

Brescia (right)

All Manassas City Public Schools remain fully accredited, and six of the division’s nine schools improved their overall index scores from the previous year, according to 2026 accountability data presented to the School Board on Oct. 13.

Dr. Jennifer Cassata, executive director of accountability and finance, walked the board through Standards of Learning results and the Virginia School Performance and Support Framework. Five schools earned scores in the Meets Expectations range, up from three the year before. Baldwin Elementary and R. C. Haydon Elementary both moved into that category. Weems Elementary again posted the division’s highest score. Jennie Dean Elementary exited a prior federal Targeted Support and Improvement designation.

Osbourn High School and Grace E. Metz Middle School also reached Meets Expectations range scores, but their published labels were lowered one level because of Targeted Support and Improvement designations based on the performance of students with disabilities. Baldwin Intermediate and Metz had their labels lowered to Needs Intensive Support despite score gains. Mayfield Intermediate’s score rounded to the Meets threshold but was labeled Approaching Expectations for the same reason. George C. Round Elementary remains in Comprehensive Support and Improvement status (year two of a three-year cycle) and cannot exit that designation yet.

Cassata said growth in reading and math is a relative strength for most schools. Division-wide reading rose slightly from 55% to 57%, with notable gains at the elementary and middle school levels. Math was essentially level, moving from 57% to 56%. Intermediate math and Algebra I at Osbourn remain areas of focus. All elementary and intermediate schools posted chronic absenteeism rates under 17%.

The Virginia Department of Education has commended the division’s aligned supports for previously identified schools, including 90-minute instructional blocks, high-quality materials, and the addition of special education teachers on special assignment.

During board comments, member Sara Brescia described the results as mixed. She said the division is not on track to meet targets in its current strategic plan, has no distinguished schools, and that only three of nine schools meet expectations in absolute terms, with student achievement still too low. At the same time, she said pockets of growth should be commended and expanded.

Brescia then rejected what she called a myth about the division’s students and schools.

“There is a myth out there about our students and about our schools, and it needs to die,” she said. “The myth that this city likes to tell itself about our schools is that we face the struggles that we face are because we have a high share of students who do not speak English at home and that we have a high share of students from different cultural backgrounds. And I also sometimes hear that the reason for our lagging student achievement is because our students, many of them, are economically disadvantaged.”

She compared Weems Elementary, the division’s highest-performing school under state criteria for two consecutive years, with George C. Round Elementary. Weems serves a population that is 80% Hispanic and 65% English learners and is succeeding. Round serves a population that is 63% Hispanic and 53% English learners. Both schools serve the same share of economically disadvantaged students.

“It is not the kids. It is not where they come from. It is not the language or languages they speak. It is not the parents,” Brescia said. “There is no such thing as a demographic destiny. All of our kids can succeed. I know this because there are schools right here in our own division where they do succeed.”

She urged residents and officials to interrupt and correct the claim when they hear it.

Chair Jill Spall said she was encouraged by the six improved scores and the movement of Baldwin and Haydon into Meets Expectations, while noting more work remains. Individual schools are scheduled to present their continuous improvement plans at the Oct. 27 and Nov. 10 board meetings.

Sara Brescia is seeking reelection to one of three at-large seats on the Manassas City School Board in the Nov. 3 general election. The other candidates on the ballot are incumbent Lisa Anne Stevens, Murina V. Dove, Marcus S. Still, Raul O. Campoverde Lindao, and Javanese M. Hailey.

The Manassas & Manassas Park Cities Democratic Committee has endorsed Stevens, Dove, and Still. School Board races in Virginia are nonpartisan. Early voting began Sept. 18.

Subscribe to our FREE email newsletter to get local news you can trust.