Finn, an urban planning professional and Chair of the Fredericksburg Planning Commission, brings a decade of experience in city planning and holds a certification from the American Institute of Certified Planners. She also has an educational background in historic preservation from the University of Mary Washington.
“Fredericksburg, and particularly Ward 3, is where my family and I have planted our roots, grown, and thrived,” Finn stated in a press release. “I am excited about the bright future of our city and confident that with genuine collaboration, we can overcome challenges and enact positive solutions.”
Selection Process and Transparency Concerns
Dr. Duffy’s resignation, effective January 1, 2025, triggered the city’s charter-mandated process to fill the vacancy. According to the city, applications were accepted through January 15, and City Council members met in a closed session to review the applications and interview four candidates before selecting Finn.
However, the selection process has drawn criticism from some residents who sought greater transparency. The city declined to release background materials on all candidates, citing legal provisions that allow for privacy protections in such appointments.
In a statement, the city claims it withheld resumes and applicants’ personal information, which were exempt from public inspection.
Despite this, some residents argue that transparency should take precedence. A Fredericksburg resident has filed a petition in Circuit Court demanding the release of applications, interview notes, and related materials. The petition also seeks to block the City Council from holding closed meetings on matters concerning the appointment process, according to a report from FXBG Advance.
Public Reaction and Next Steps
Finn’s appointment has been met with both support and skepticism. While many applaud her qualifications and commitment to the community, others are concerned about the lack of public scrutiny in the selection process.
The Fredericksburg City Council has expressed gratitude to all applicants who showed interest in the role. The 14 candidates who applied included Scott Cole, Jesus Dominguez, Eugene Gormley, Thomas Johnson, Matthew Kelly, Avery LaBelle, Evan Lawson, Shawn McDonald, John Simpson, Laura Matter, Rene Rodriguez, Pamela Scruggs, and Shaliek Tarpley.
Finn will serve as Ward 3’s City Council representative through December 31, 2025. Whether the legal challenge will impact future appointment procedures remains to be seen.
Background on Dr. Timothy Duffy’s Resignation
Dr. Tim Duffy announced his resignation from the Fredericksburg City Council during a meeting on December 10, 2024, citing personal and family health challenges. His resignation took effect on January 1, 2025.
Dr. Duffy shared that recent developments within his family and his ongoing battle with prostate cancer, initially treated in 2019, prompted him to reprioritize his commitments. He expressed immense gratitude for the opportunity to serve the community and collaborate with fellow council members and city staff.
